Page 1 of 1

Pitchfork. Pretentious crap? Or ...

PostPosted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 11:57 pm
by docfalken
What Spin magazine always wanted to be?

I'm not sure what I feel about that site. It is very much a love/hate relationship with me.

Maybe I'm just pissed that they've got 15 ads for every page and yet they keep their "street cred".

PostPosted: Mon Aug 15, 2005 11:58 pm
by Adam Balm
You know what I like about AICN? CHUD and Superherohype.com both freeze my browser with all the goddamn ads they have.

PostPosted: Tue Aug 16, 2005 12:04 am
by Keepcoolbutcare
oh fuck yeah it's pretentious and I love it that way. With all the Dave Eggers McSweeney's and Believer no snark school of criticism out there it's fun to read a music site that will kick you in the balls.

Plus they've responded to criticism...no longer as "rockist" as they once were. It still don't think they review hip-hop enough (where in the hell is the Felt 2 review...Murs & Slug for pete's sake!) and they do push certain acts a little too hard but to me it's very similiar to AICN. 'Cept they push the "cool". Harry & Co. tastes run a bit more populist.

PostPosted: Tue Aug 16, 2005 12:51 am
by Octaveaeon
read their review of the latest "Audioslave" album.... they get my vote...

PostPosted: Fri Sep 09, 2005 3:58 pm
by TonyWilson
Oh wow I hadn't seen this thread until just now.

I love Pitchfork, I've been visiting since '98 when they had one of the few positive Bran Van 3000 reviews around. Brent DiCrescenzo wrote it, he also gave Kid A a 10.0 which is like the Pitchfork holy grail, only around 8 albums have it. Miles Davis, Endtroducing, Kid A and I think a couple of Tom Waits one's. I trust their reviews because they seem to be into the same things as me, although maybe I just listen to what they recommend too much. They got me into the Fiery Furnaces though so they get unlimited respect for that.


Anyhoo I wanted to post on here that "The Notwist" are playing over the shopgirl adds on the mainsite. If you've not heard them go take a quck listen and see if you like 'em.

PostPosted: Fri Sep 09, 2005 4:09 pm
by burlivesleftnut
I have that notwist album. I bought it after a review I read somewhere... Maybe OnionAVClub. But the album is kind of dull. Technically phenomenal, just boring.

PostPosted: Fri Sep 09, 2005 4:13 pm
by TonyWilson
Is that the one called "Neon Golden"? it has a red cover. Yeh it can be a bit drab i guess. The first one is called "Shrink" and I like it a lot more. Definitely more poppy but still kind of melancholy.

PostPosted: Fri Sep 09, 2005 4:22 pm
by burlivesleftnut
Yes I have neon golden. I will check out the other since you make it seem more lively.

PostPosted: Sun Sep 11, 2005 12:00 am
by Keepcoolbutcare
Pitchfork and T.V on the Radio team up to give out a free tune.

Check it here...

http://www.tgrec.com/news/detail.php?id=101

PostPosted: Fri Dec 09, 2005 5:31 pm
by Pudie
TonyWilson wrote:Oh wow I hadn't seen this thread until just now.

I love Pitchfork, I've been visiting since '98 when they had one of the few positive Bran Van 3000 reviews around. Brent DiCrescenzo wrote it, he also gave Kid A a 10.0 which is like the Pitchfork holy grail, only around 8 albums have it. Miles Davis, Endtroducing, Kid A and I think a couple of Tom Waits one's. I trust their reviews because they seem to be into the same things as me, although maybe I just listen to what they recommend too much. They got me into the Fiery Furnaces though so they get unlimited respect for that.


Anyhoo I wanted to post on here that "The Notwist" are playing over the shopgirl adds on the mainsite. If you've not heard them go take a quck listen and see if you like 'em.


That Radiohead review is the most agonizing read ever.

PostPosted: Fri Dec 09, 2005 5:32 pm
by TonyWilson
Pudie wrote:
TonyWilson wrote:Oh wow I hadn't seen this thread until just now.

I love Pitchfork, I've been visiting since '98 when they had one of the few positive Bran Van 3000 reviews around. Brent DiCrescenzo wrote it, he also gave Kid A a 10.0 which is like the Pitchfork holy grail, only around 8 albums have it. Miles Davis, Endtroducing, Kid A and I think a couple of Tom Waits one's. I trust their reviews because they seem to be into the same things as me, although maybe I just listen to what they recommend too much. They got me into the Fiery Furnaces though so they get unlimited respect for that.


Anyhoo I wanted to post on here that "The Notwist" are playing over the shopgirl adds on the mainsite. If you've not heard them go take a quck listen and see if you like 'em.


That Radiohead review is the most agonizing read ever.


Oh agreed. But he got the Rating right.

PostPosted: Tue Dec 20, 2005 6:59 pm
by Keepcoolbutcare
Pitchfork's Top 50 Albums of 2005

agree, disagree, fuck them snarky @ssholes?

PostPosted: Tue Dec 20, 2005 7:34 pm
by TonyWilson
*spoiler*

Illinois at number 1???? No bloody way.
MIA at number 4????? Swap those 2 over and get rid of Late Registration and tha tlist looks much better.


*end spoiler*

Ok sometimes the pretension gets annoying but it's worth skimming over that for the genuine insights and post post post meta modern ideas the site come up with.

PostPosted: Tue Dec 20, 2005 7:40 pm
by Keepcoolbutcare
Late Registration's gonna be near the top of a LOT of lists. Deep breaths Tony, deep breaths. (or, countdown from 10!)

Agree with the MIA and Sufjan swap tho'...

PostPosted: Tue Dec 20, 2005 7:44 pm
by TonyWilson
I don't mind Late Registration, but top 10 of the year??? I'd argue College Dropout was the better hip hop album. Registration is great but the production can be very overwrought and West is not a great rapper by any means. In fact that counting down from 10 is sounding like a good idea now.

PostPosted: Tue Dec 20, 2005 8:26 pm
by vicious_bastard
Nice to see Roisin Murphy's 'Ruby Blue' getting a nod - great voice, great album. Got no love.

PostPosted: Mon Sep 10, 2007 9:40 am
by stereosforgeeks

PostPosted: Mon Apr 07, 2008 8:15 pm
by Keepcoolbutcare
P4K TV launched today - Radiohead doing "Bangers 'n Mash" w/some quality drumming from Thom, and Liars absolutely killing "Plaster Casts of Everything".

good stuff, haven't noticed any issues, which, for a beta version, is pretty shocking...

PostPosted: Mon Apr 07, 2008 9:54 pm
by King Psyz
while I have no love lost for the fork, whoever did their new webdesign for the tv site is a fuckin hero.

I hate going to sites with video where you have to stop or leave the video to see what else is going on. I was actually hesitant to click on the nav bar for that reason but I'm not the world's biggest radiohead fan either...

But yeah, clicking on links not shutting down the video player is the shiznit. Too bad it will be blocked by websense within 48 hours...

Re: Pitchfork. Pretentious crap? Or ...

PostPosted: Sat Sep 13, 2008 9:41 am
by R.Sammy
I don't always agree with pitchfork, but I appreciate their different approach to music criticism. I can never trust music reviews in mainstream mags like spin and rolling stone as they give positive reviews to a lot of crap. At least with Pitchfork they hate just about everything, so if they give it a positive review there is probably something worth looking into.

Re:

PostPosted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 4:20 pm
by Ribbons
stereosforgeeks wrote:Onion: Pitchfork gives music 6.8


IPAMPILASH!

Re: Pitchfork. Pretentious crap? Or ...

PostPosted: Tue Mar 31, 2009 1:25 am
by criticalbliss
docfalken wrote:What Spin magazine always wanted to be?

I'm not sure what I feel about that site. It is very much a love/hate relationship with me.

Maybe I'm just pissed that they've got 15 ads for every page and yet they keep their "street cred".


Pitchforkmedia, ultimately, is hipster, coffee-shop crap. Yes, they happen to be right every once in a while, but just as often they are wrong. The second any band becomes popular, they dump all over them. It's reflexive and pseudo-intellectual, more concerned with what people think of their reviews than the validity of their criticism.

Still, I can't name too many review sites that aren't compromised in some way. They are better than Rollingstone, at least (admittedly, not a difficult proposition).